The nearest pizza option is not always the right one for the shape of dinner you have in mind. In Brickell, Mister O1 Extraordinary Pizza makes a thin 13-inch Star Luca with ricotta-filled points, while a separate Nutella pizza handles the sweet finish. Downtown has counter-service slices and Sicilian squares, Little River leans towards sourdough and natural wine, and Miami Beach offers candlelit whole pies. This guide puts the useful details in one place: addresses, opening times, prices, booking rules, parking and the transport catch that makes these restaurants poor candidates for one ambitious walking crawl.
Ask Karpo in the app which Miami pizza stop fits your neighbourhood, preferred pie and dinner time. You can also ask for the best order and the simplest route before you leave.
Mister O1 Extraordinary Pizza, Brickell — folds a star-shaped pie
Start at Mister O1 Extraordinary Pizza if your search for pizza near me has brought you to Brickell and you want something more distinctive than a standard round. The casual Italian pizzeria specialises in thin 13-inch pies, including the $21.99 Star Luca, whose points are filled with ricotta. The important correction is that Nutella does not top those star points: it belongs to a separate dessert pizza, priced at $14.99, or $10.99 in the small size. The room has a visible pizza kitchen, while the larger patio adds dark metal seating, greenery and lights.
Mister O1 is at 900 S Miami Ave, Suite 130, Brickell, Miami, FL 33130, near the Brickell Metrorail and Metromover station. It opens Monday to Thursday from 11:30 AM to 11 PM, Friday from 11:30 AM to midnight, Saturday from noon to midnight and Sunday from noon to 11 PM. Seating is walk-in only, with no reservations accepted. Choose it for a personal-size speciality pie, an easy Brickell stop or a dessert pizza after the savoury order rather than for a long, pre-booked evening.
Eleventh Street Pizza, Park West / Downtown Miami — orders slices late
Eleventh Street Pizza is the practical Downtown alternative: a compact counter-service shop for dine-in and takeout, making sourdough New York-style rounds alongside thick rectangular Sicilian pies. The room is deliberately spare, with vivid orange banquettes, exposed purple rafters, tightly grouped tables and a small row of covered outdoor seats. The useful warning concerns the $27 pepperoni-and-hot-honey Sicilian, which takes approximately 45 minutes. Order it before the rest of the table gets hungry, particularly if you have arrived for a late meal rather than a quick slice.
The address is 1035 N Miami Ave, Suite 103, Park West, Miami, FL 33136. Hours are Monday to Wednesday from 4 to 11 PM, Thursday from 4 PM to midnight, Friday and Saturday from noon to 2 AM, and Sunday from noon to midnight. A 14-inch classic cheese pie is $20; the pepperoni and hot honey version is $27; Sicilian pies run from $36 to $38. This suits groups near Downtown bars, counter-service diners and anyone who values a later closing over table service.
La Natural, Little River — settles in over sourdough and wine
La Natural takes the slower route, with a full-service restaurant built around wood-fired, naturally leavened sourdough pizza, vegetable-driven plates and natural wine. Its Little River setting feels open to the air: concrete floors, blond-wood tables, wicker chairs and ceiling fans sit behind garage doors, while fruit bowls line the rear bar. Current pizzas include a $22 fior-di-latte and basil pie and a $25 wild-mushroom version, with most pizzas priced between $21 and $25. It is the choice when pizza is part of a proper dinner rather than a stop between drinks.
La Natural is at 7289 NW 2nd Ave, Little River, Miami, FL 33150. Dinner runs Monday to Thursday from 5 to 10 PM; Friday and Saturday offer lunch from noon to 3 PM and dinner from 5 to 11 PM; Sunday runs noon to 3 PM and 5 to 10 PM. The restaurant closes between 3 and 5 PM on Friday through Sunday, and online reservations are recommended. Pick it for a date-night pace, weekend lunch or a sourdough pie with natural wine, not for an unplanned central Miami walk-up.
Lucali, Sunset Harbour — orders a whole pie by candlelight
Lucali is the Miami Beach contrast to Brickell's personal-size specialties and Downtown's counter slices. The Brooklyn outpost serves thin, blistered whole pies and calzones from an open wood-fired kitchen in an unfussy rustic room of mismatched wooden tables and chairs. Low candlelight does most of the decorating. A signature plain or white pie is $30, a small calzone is $21 and a Nutella pie is $20. The restaurant explicitly accepts no phone orders; its published online-order option is Uber Eats, so do not plan around calling ahead.
You will find Lucali at 1930 Bay Rd, Sunset Harbour, Miami Beach, FL 33139. It opens Monday to Thursday from noon to 11 PM, Friday and Saturday from noon to midnight, and Sunday from noon to 11 PM. This is the right fit for a sit-down meal centred on a large handmade pie, a calzone or the candlelit room itself. It is less suitable when you are already in Brickell and want the nearest answer, because reaching Sunset Harbour requires a causeway trip to Miami Beach.
How to choose
For Brickell, choose Mister O1: the Star Luca is the most specific answer to the headline's promise, and the separate Nutella pizza gives you the dessert option without confusing it with the ricotta-filled star points. Choose Eleventh Street Pizza for a quicker Downtown decision, especially if the group wants both thin New York-style and Sicilian. Its later Friday and Saturday closing is useful, but the pepperoni-and-hot-honey Sicilian needs roughly 45 minutes. La Natural wins when the meal should slow down around sourdough, vegetable-led plates and natural wine. Lucali is the whole-pie, candlelit choice in Miami Beach.
The distances matter more than a four-restaurant list suggests. Mister O1 is near the Brickell Metrorail and Metromover station. Mary Brickell Village's garage entrance is on SW 10th Street and currently charges $8 for the first hour or $16 for up to two hours; it does not accept cash. Eleventh Street Pizza is roughly 320 metres from Eleventh Street Metromover, but its midnight and 2 AM closings run beyond Metromover's published 10 PM shutdown, so late diners need another return option. Lucali requires a causeway trip, and La Natural is well north in Little River. Treat them as separate plans, not one walking crawl.
One correction before you search
Some older guides still list Mister O1 Brickell at 1000 S Miami Ave and give the phone number (786) 332-6868. The operating location is now 900 S Miami Ave, Suite 130, and the current phone number is (305) 902-1605. Use the newer address when searching for directions or arranging your Brickell pizza stop, otherwise you may send yourself to the wrong end of South Miami Avenue before the first slice is even ordered.
Please drink responsibly. Must be of legal drinking age.
Tags: #pizzanearme #miamipizza #brickellrestaurants #mistero1 #mistero1pizza #eleventhstreetpizza #parkwest #downtownmiami #lanatural #littleriver #lucali #sunsetharbour #miamibeach #starluca
All trademarks are the property of their respective owners.
Ask Karpo first
Before leaving, ask Karpo in the app to compare the four restaurants by your starting point, desired arrival time, pie style and budget. Check whether you need a reservation at La Natural, allow extra time for Eleventh Street Pizza's pepperoni-and-hot-honey Sicilian, and decide whether Brickell garage parking or public transport works best. If you are choosing Lucali or La Natural, ask for the route order first rather than treating the venues as one walking crawl.
