Second Avenue has a coffee shop roughly every ninety seconds, and almost all of them are selling the same thing at the same price. La Cabra is doing something structurally different, and the difference is visible the moment you look at the counter: this is a roaster that decided to become a bakery as well, and the bakery is now the reason most people are in the queue.
The pastry case, not the espresso machine, is what makes this worth crossing avenues for.
What it is
La Cabra's East Village room is at 152 Second Avenue. Hours are 7am to 6pm Monday to Friday, and 8am to 6pm at weekends.
The company is a Nordic roaster and the coffee reflects it — light, clean, acid-forward, sold both brewed and as beans to take home, with a seasonal rotation rather than a fixed house blend. If your reference point is a dark, chocolatey American espresso, this will taste thin at first and then, usually, better.
The bakery side is not a bolt-on. There is naturally leavened sourdough, hand-laminated croissants, and a changing list of pastries from a team led by head baker Jared Sexton, who came through the kitchens at Bien Cuit, Pain D'Avignon and Dominique Ansel Bakery. That is a serious bakery pedigree for a coffee shop and it shows in the case.
The cardamom bun
The house favourite is the cardamom bun, and it deserves the status. The dough is laminated and coiled, the cardamom is used at a level that would be considered reckless in most American bakeries, and there are crunchy bits of sugar baked into the interior rather than merely scattered on top — which is the detail that separates it from every imitator on the avenue.
The practical problem is that it is baked in finite quantity and it is the single most-requested item in the case. Mid-morning is the reliable window. Arriving at 4pm and expecting one is optimistic, and arriving at 5.30pm on a Saturday is a plan with no chance of success.
If it is gone: the laminated croissants are the next order, and they are made to the same standard. The sourdough is a take-home item rather than a sit-down one.
How to use the room
This is a bright, pale, minimal space and it is not a work café. There is seating but it is finite and it turns over; the design signals a twenty-minute visit rather than a three-hour one, and at peak the pressure from the queue makes that explicit.
For a coffee meeting with one other person, it is close to ideal — good enough coffee that neither of you is compromising, and a pastry programme that gives the meeting a reason to be somewhere rather than at a desk. For solo laptop work, look elsewhere; the East Village has better options and this room will make you feel it.
There is a second Manhattan location at 284 Lafayette Street in SoHo and a roastery at 1329 Willoughby Avenue in Brooklyn. The Lafayette room is the one to use if you are downtown and want the same pastries with a slightly different rhythm.
What to order beyond the bun
Order filter rather than a milk drink at least once. The whole point of a Nordic roasting profile is that it is built to be tasted black, and the milk drinks — which are perfectly good — flatten exactly the acidity the roast is designed to produce.
If you want to take the coffee home, ask what has been roasted most recently rather than picking by origin. A light roast is at its best in a fairly narrow window after roasting, and the staff will tell you which bag is in it.
The seasonal rotation means the espresso in March is not the espresso in September. That is the intended behaviour, not an inconsistency, and it is worth asking what changed if you are a regular who thinks something tastes different.
The queue, and how to avoid most of it
The line here is a morning phenomenon and it is heavily concentrated. Between roughly 8.30am and 10.30am on a weekday you are joining office and student traffic; between 10am and 1pm at a weekend you are joining everybody else in the neighbourhood.
The reliable windows are 7am to 8am on a weekday — quiet, everything just out of the oven, and the most pleasant version of the room — and mid-afternoon on a weekday, when the pastry case is thinner but the queue is gone.
If you are buying for a group, order ahead of the person paying rather than deciding at the counter. A group of four working out drinks at the front of a fifteen-person queue is the main reason the line moves slowly, and the room is small enough that it is noticeable.
One more practical note: the pastry case is the part that empties, not the coffee. If the bakery matters more to you than the espresso, treat opening time as the target and everything after noon as a lottery.
Practical notes
La Cabra, 152 Second Avenue, East Village, New York. Hours: Monday–Friday 7am–6pm; Saturday–Sunday 8am–6pm. Nordic-style light roasting, seasonal coffees, brewed and whole bean. Bakery led by head baker Jared Sexton — naturally leavened sourdough, hand-laminated croissants and rotating pastries. The cardamom bun is the house favourite and sells through; mid-morning is the safest window. Limited seating, high turnover — not a laptop café. Other locations: 284 Lafayette Street, SoHo; roastery at 1329 Willoughby Avenue, Brooklyn. Hours and menu change — confirm before travelling for a specific pastry.
Tags: #coffeenearme #lacabra #eastvillage #cardamombun #nyccoffee #nordiccoffee #nycbakery #secondavenue #nyceats #lightroast #croissant #nyccafes #wheretoeatnyc #newyorkfood
All trademarks are the property of their respective owners.
Ask Karpo first
Want to know whether the cardamom buns are still in the case before you walk to Second Avenue? Ask Karpo what the queue looks like now, which La Cabra room is quieter this hour, and two nearby cafés that will actually let you sit with a laptop.
