There is one test that sorts San Francisco taquerias faster than any ranking, and it takes about two seconds at the counter: does the tortilla come out of this building or off a delivery truck. It is not a snobbish distinction. A tortilla pressed and cooked on site has a different texture, a different smell and a shorter shelf life, and a kitchen that has committed to making them has committed to a whole set of other things as well. The city has a handful of places that do it, and they are not all in the neighbourhood you would guess.
House-made tortillas change the taco entirely, and the counters that press their own are scattered across four neighbourhoods. Ask Karpo which one is closest and open.
The Oldest Answer Is on 24th Street
La Palma Mexicatessen at 2884 24th Street has been wrapping grilled meat and vegetables in tortillas made in its own building since 1953. That date does most of the work here. This is not a restaurant that added a tortilla programme; it is a tortilleria that grew a counter around itself, which is a different institution with different priorities.
What that means in practice is that the tortilla is the product and the filling is the accompaniment, which is the reverse of how most taco menus are organised. Order accordingly. The plainest thing on the menu will tell you more about the kitchen than the most elaborate one, and in a room that has been pressing masa in the same building for over seventy years, plain is the point.
Two blocks along the same street, La Vaca Birria at 2962 24th Street is the newest entry in this category and it makes handmade nixtamal corn tortillas, alongside six-hour braised American Black Angus beef, mesquite-fired carne asada and smoky salsas. Nixtamal is the specific detail worth registering: it means the corn is processed with an alkaline solution before grinding, which is the traditional method and the one that produces the flavour people associate with a real corn tortilla.
The Richmond Outlier
The neighbourhood most people never associate with tacos holds one of the better answers. Taqueria Los Mayas at 331 Clement Street in the Inner Richmond cooks Yucatecan food from family recipes, with handmade tortillas used across tacos, panuchos and burritos.
Panuchos are the reason to pay attention. They are a Yucatecan preparation in which a tortilla is stuffed with refried black beans before frying, and they are close to impossible to do well with a bought-in tortilla because the tortilla has to be fresh enough to puff and split cleanly. A menu that includes them is a menu that has solved the tortilla problem, and the dish itself is uncommon in this city.
It is also a useful geographic correction. Clement Street is not the Mission, it is across town in the Richmond, and anyone who assumes San Francisco's good Mexican food is confined to one district is skipping an entire regional cuisine sitting forty blocks west.
The Family Rooms and the Famous One
Taqueria El Buen Sabor at 699 Valencia Street has been family-owned and operated in the Mission since 1995, more than thirty years, with everything on the menu made in house from family recipes. That in-house commitment is the same signal as the tortilla test applied across a whole kitchen.
La Taqueria at 2889 Mission Street, anchored at 25th, is the most nationally decorated taqueria in the city and routinely tops lists for both tacos and burritos. It is worth eating at, and it is worth knowing that its reputation rests on a particular and slightly unusual approach rather than on doing the standard thing better than everyone else, which is why opinions about it are so divided among people who eat here regularly.
Beyond those, the current field named on local lists runs wide: El Farolito, Taqueria Vallarta, Donaji, Tacos El Patron, Tacos El Tucan, Suavecito Birria and Tacos, Leo's Tacos and El Rey Taquiza Artesanal among others. That breadth is the actual state of tacos in San Francisco, and it is considerably larger than the three or four names that dominate national coverage.
How to Run the Test
Three things to look for. First, ask directly whether the tortillas are made here; it is a normal question and the answer is instant. Second, look at the stack. House tortillas are irregular in outline, slightly thicker and often visibly steamed under a cloth rather than sitting in a plastic sleeve. Third, watch what happens on the griddle: a fresh tortilla puffs when it hits heat, and a bought-in one mostly does not.
One practical note about ordering. In a place making its own, the single taco is the correct unit of investigation rather than the burrito, because a burrito buries the tortilla under everything else. Order two tacos of the plainest thing available, judge those, and then decide what else to have. That sequence costs about six dollars and settles the question completely.
Practical notes
La Palma Mexicatessen, 2884 24th St - tortillas made in the building since 1953. La Vaca Birria, 2962 24th St - handmade nixtamal corn tortillas, six-hour braised American Black Angus beef, mesquite-fired carne asada, smoky salsas. Taqueria Los Mayas, 331 Clement St, Inner Richmond - Yucatecan recipes, handmade tortillas, tacos, panuchos and burritos. Taqueria El Buen Sabor, 699 Valencia St - family owned since 1995, everything made in house. La Taqueria, 2889 Mission St at 25th. Other names in current circulation include El Farolito, Taqueria Vallarta, Donaji, Tacos El Patron, Tacos El Tucan, Suavecito Birria and Tacos, Leo's Tacos and El Rey Taquiza Artesanal. Confirm hours before travelling.
Tags: #besttacos #sanfrancisco #tacos #missiondistrict #lapalmamexicatessen #lavacabirria #tortillas #nixtamal #taquerialosmayas #innerrichmond #sffood #mexicanfood #sfguide #24thstreet
All trademarks are the property of their respective owners.
Ask Karpo first
The counters pressing their own tortillas are scattered from 24th Street to Clement Street and several keep short hours. Ask Karpo which house-tortilla taqueria near you is open right now, how long the queue is, and what to order first to judge the kitchen.
