ZZ's Clam Bar was a twelve-seat raw bar at 169 Thompson Street that held a Michelin star from 2014 until 2022 and closed in 2023. Major Food Group converted the space into private dining for Carbone next door. If a list has sent you there, the door is not a restaurant any more, and it is worth knowing what the room did because its influence is everywhere downtown.
Thompson Street still has the restaurant that absorbed this room, and the raw-bar format it popularised is now spread across a dozen small rooms downtown. Ask Karpo what is open and bookable nearby tonight for oysters and crudo.
What it actually was
A very small room, run by the same group behind Carbone, serving raw seafood in a format that barely existed in New York at the time — a menu organised not by ingredient but by preparation. Toast, ceviche, tartare, crudo, seared, carpaccio. You chose the treatment and the kitchen chose the fish.
That structure sounds like a small thing and it was the whole idea. It moved the emphasis from what the fish is to what has been done to it, which is how a kitchen thinks and not how a menu usually reads. It also let the room change its sourcing daily without rewriting anything.
The pricing was famously extreme in both directions. Clams at a dollar and a half sat on the same list as a carpaccio at a hundred and five dollars, which was either a provocation or an unusually honest expression of what different raw seafood actually costs.
Why it mattered
New York had oyster bars and it had sushi. What it did not have much of was a room treating European-style raw preparations — crudo, tartare, carpaccio — as a full menu rather than as three items at the start of an Italian one.
A Michelin star for a twelve-seat raw bar was, at the time, a genuinely unusual award and it validated the format. In the decade since, small raw-focused rooms have opened across the Lower East Side, the West Village and Brooklyn, and a great many of them are recognisably downstream of this one.
The star ran from 2014 to 2022 and the restaurant closed the following year. Twelve seats is not a business that survives a shock, and the group's decision to convert the space into private dining for its far more profitable neighbour is a straightforwardly rational one.
Where the format went
The good news for anyone searching for this is that the thing ZZ's was scarce for is no longer scarce. Raw bars with a serious crudo programme are now spread across downtown Manhattan and Brooklyn, most of them small, most of them walk-in friendly at the bar, and most of them considerably cheaper than a hundred-and-five-dollar carpaccio.
The Mermaid Inn group runs the accessible end of this — oysters, a lobster roll, a real happy hour — across Chelsea, the Upper West Side and Times Square. That is a different proposition entirely and it is the right one if what you actually want is a plate of oysters and a drink without an event attached.
At the other end, the Grand Central Oyster Bar has been doing raw shellfish under the terminal since 1913 and carries up to thirty varieties at once, though it is closed at weekends.
What happened to the ZZ's name
The name did not disappear. Major Food Group opened ZZ's Club in Hudson Yards in 2023 — a private members' club rather than a restaurant, with the raw-bar concept absorbed into it. Membership is expensive and it is not something you can walk into.
That trajectory is worth noting because it is a pattern rather than an anomaly. A well-regarded small restaurant becomes a brand, the brand becomes more valuable than the room, and the room becomes either a members' club or private dining. It has happened repeatedly in this city over the last five years.
The practical consequence is that a name in a search result is not evidence of a public restaurant. Checking whether something is open to the general public, and not only whether it exists, is a step worth taking.
How to order raw seafood well
Since the format is now widely available, the useful thing is knowing how to use it. Order fewer preparations than you want to try — three raw dishes for two people is plenty, and four is where palate fatigue starts and everything begins to taste of citrus and oil.
Ask what came in. A raw-fish menu is only as good as the day's delivery, and any kitchen serious about this will have a clear answer and a preference. The dish the kitchen is pleased with is almost always better than the dish you would have picked from the description.
And eat at the bar. Raw preparations are assembled rather than cooked, which means the whole process is visible from a counter seat and invisible from a table. That was true at ZZ's and it is true at every room that followed it.
Practical notes
ZZ's Clam Bar at 169 Thompson Street closed in 2023 and the space is now private dining for Carbone — it is not a restaurant you can visit. It held a Michelin star from 2014 to 2022. The ZZ's name continues as ZZ's Club in Hudson Yards, a private members' club rather than a public room. For oysters and raw seafood now: the Mermaid Inn locations in Chelsea at 227 10th Avenue and the Upper West Side at 335 Columbus Avenue run daily happy hours; the Grand Central Oyster Bar carries up to thirty oyster varieties but is closed at weekends. Order three raw dishes for two, ask what came in, and sit at the bar.
Tags: #zzsclambar #bestseafoodnyc #seafoodnearme #greenwichvillage #crudo #rawbar #thompsonstreet #majorfoodgroup #closedNYC #nycrestaurants #newyorkfood #nycfoodguide #oystersnyc #nyceats
Please drink responsibly. Must be of legal drinking age.
All trademarks are the property of their respective owners.
Ask Karpo first
The room that made this format famous is gone, but the format itself is now spread across a dozen small downtown bars with very different prices. Ask Karpo which raw bars near you are open and taking walk-ins tonight, what a plate of oysters is running at, and which of them has a bar seat free right now.
