The Law That Built the Loophole
Raines Law Room takes its name from a piece of 1896 New York State legislation. On March 23 of that year, Republican State Senator John Raines pushed through a bill restricting Sunday liquor sales to hotels — establishments with at least ten rentable rooms and amenities. The intent was revenue and moral reform. The result was chaos of a specific, delightful New York kind.
Saloon operators across the city promptly converted back rooms into nominal hotel rooms, producing what historians call Raines Law Hotels. By one 1902 count there were just 13 hotels in Brooklyn before the law passed; a few years later there were more than 1,000 in that borough alone, with some estimates putting the statewide total between 4,000 and 5,000. Many became brothels and gambling operations. The law also produced the "Raines sandwich" — fake food set on tables to technically comply with meal-service requirements, reputedly so stale that regulars learned never to touch it.
The bar named after this law opened on West 17th Street in Chelsea in 2009. Not as a nostalgia exercise, and not as irony. As a genuine argument about what an evening can be — and what happens when one small act of entry changes all of it.
What a Doorbell Changes
Every bar in New York is making a pitch the moment you step inside. Exposed brick, a particular song, a bartender who makes eye contact at the right moment — the edit starts at the threshold. Raines Law Room runs its edit earlier than that, before you've opened any door, before you've seen a single surface of the interior.
You find the address on West 17th Street. There is no sign. You find the bell. You press it. Then there are three or four seconds where you don't know if anyone heard, and you consider whether to press it again, and then the door opens.
That pause is doing real work. It has already separated this evening from every other evening in the city. You arrived at something. You didn't just walk in.
The Room
The space inside is not large. The design — by Delphine Mauroit — draws from 19th-century English townhouses, and the execution is sincere rather than stagey. Heavy-framed sofas upholstered in dark fabric. Wood paneling. Amber lamp glow settling over small side tables. Velvet drapery. Hand-finished bells connected to the kitchen. Concealed doors. The whole room commits to a particular, unhurried century and goes further than you expect.
The no-standing rule holds. There is nowhere to stand — seating is arranged so that everyone in the room is seated, which means everyone has committed to being there. In most of New York's bars, standing is the default posture: you stand while you wait, stand at the bar, stand in the crowd. At Raines, fifteen minutes after you've sat down, the evening has slowed in a way that's hard to explain but easy to feel. The physics of sitting are different from the physics of standing.
An outdoor garden extends behind the main rooms — discovered mostly by accident on a second or third visit. The space is built underneath the Chelsea Inn Hotel, which keeps the ceiling lower than expected. That, combined with the lamplight, makes the room feel more interior, more private, more genuinely removed from the sidewalk above.
The Cocktail Menu
Bar director Meaghan Dorman built a program of roughly forty cocktails running classics alongside seasonal originals. The menu rewards reading — it is dense with specific choices rather than padded with variations on the same three templates. Service delivers drinks to your seat, which means no flagging down attention across a crowded bar, no navigating a standing-room floor.
What this formality produces — and it is genuine formality, not performance — is a different relationship with the drink in your hand. You ordered deliberately. You waited for it at a table. You received it from someone who walked it to you. In most of the city, a cocktail is something you get; here, it is something that arrives.
Why 2009 Still Matters
When Raines Law Room opened, the craft cocktail revival in New York was still building its vocabulary. A bar that required a doorbell, refused standing, and was designed to look like a Victorian parlor was genuinely odd — not the kind of strange that gets immediately copied, but the kind that makes you wonder if it will last the year.
It has now been open for fifteen years. That longevity says something about the specificity of the edit. This bar is not trying to be everything to everyone. The doorbell stays. The rules stay. The room stays.
The Chelsea location at West 17th Street is currently temporarily closed following a fire in the building. A sister location — Raines Law Room at The William, inside a preserved 1924 townhouse at 24 East 39th Street — carries the same concept forward: the cocktail parlors, the same seated-only logic, the same idea that entry is part of the experience.
Practical notes
- Address: 48 W 17th Street, New York, NY 10011 (Chelsea original — temporarily closed following a building fire). Sister location: Raines Law Room at The William, 24 E 39th Street, New York, NY 10016
- Hours (The William): Mon–Thu 5pm–12am; Fri 5pm–2am; Sat 4pm–2am
- Getting there: For Chelsea when open: 1/2/3 to 18th Street or F/M to 14th Street–6th Ave. For The William: 6 to 33rd Street, or B/D/F/M to 34th St–Herald Square
- Reservations: Available Mon–Sat via Resy; walk-ins welcomed; maximum party 8 (21+ only)
- Go for: The seasonal originals on the cocktail menu; the room itself
- Best window: A Tuesday or Wednesday at 8pm — quiet enough to actually settle into the room
- What to do after: Walk north to the Morgan Library at 36th Street, or east to Madison Square Park for air
The point
Every bar is an edit — a set of decisions about what stays in and what gets cut. Raines Law Room just makes its editing visible. The doorbell is not a gimmick; it is where the edit begins. Before you've sat down, before you've read the menu, before you've said a word to anyone inside, you've already made a different kind of choice than the one you make when you push through a door. You rang a bell on West 17th Street and you waited. That pause is the argument: this is a room that starts before the room starts.
Tags: #raineslawroom #speakeasynyc #craftcocktails #chelseabar #nychiddenbar #newyorknightlife #chelseanyc #hiddengems #nyccocktailbar #victoriandecor #slowdrinking #oddedit #karpofinds #nycbars #speakeasybar
Sources consulted: raineslawroom.com · theinfatuation.com · newyorkalmanack.com · atlasobscura.com · villagepreservation.org
All trademarks are the property of their respective owners.
Please drink responsibly. Must be of legal drinking age.
