Wild Bagels

4.0 (463)bakery

1901 Stillwell Ave

This Bensonhurst bagel shop serves oversized everything bagels alongside breakfast paninis and classic deli heroes.

Find on Google Maps

People

TommyOwner

Description

The counter serves up a wide spread, from tuna salad and muffins to wraps and chicken cutlet heroes. While locals praise the flavor of some of the best-tasting bagels in the area, the actual service is notoriously hit-or-miss. Visitors highlight frequent order mix-ups—sometimes ending up with toast instead of a bagel for their breakfast sandwich—alongside billing discrepancies at the register.


Selected reviews


Good to know

Check your billCheck your orderBuy 6, get 1 free

Also featured in

Ask Karpo for more information.