Wild Bagels
This Bensonhurst bagel shop serves oversized everything bagels alongside breakfast paninis and classic deli heroes.
- Mon – Fri, 06:00 – 19:00; Sat – Sun, 07:00 – 16:00
- 1901 Stillwell Ave
- 4.0 (463 reviews)
People
TommyOwner
Description
The counter serves up a wide spread, from tuna salad and muffins to wraps and chicken cutlet heroes. While locals praise the flavor of some of the best-tasting bagels in the area, the actual service is notoriously hit-or-miss. Visitors highlight frequent order mix-ups—sometimes ending up with toast instead of a bagel for their breakfast sandwich—alongside billing discrepancies at the register.
Good to know
Check your billCheck your orderBuy 6, get 1 free