Vito's Slices and Ices

A no-frills counter serving classic, non-drooping New York slices, house-made Italian ice, and standout vegan options.

  • Mon – Thu, Sun, 11:00 – 23:00; Fri – Sat, 11:00 – 00:00 (+1)
  • $
  • 464 9th Ave
  • 4.7 (2223 reviews)

Description

Expect a thin-slice pizza with a thick, chewy crust. The menu extends to gluten-free crusts and a vegan slice topped with melty cheese and fresh basil. For a sweet contrast, they scoop Italian ice in flavors like raspberry lime. The space itself is compact, with just 12 stools at the window counters. At lunchtime, lines regularly stretch down the block, but the counter crew keeps the orders moving quickly. Because indoor space is limited, many choose to order whole eight-slice pies online for pickup or eat their slices standing up.


Good to know

Limited seatingQuick serviceOnline pickupLong lunch lines

Ask Karpo for more information.