Van Leeuwen Ice Cream · 640 Broadway | New York

Along Broadway, this scoop shop pairs its signature bases with a menu of cookie sandwiches, sundaes, and milkshakes. While the ice cream flavors win praise—like the mango sticky rice and a scoop loaded with real honeycomb pieces—the frozen yogurt draws mixed reactions, serving as a milder option for those who find the standard scoops too sweet. The staff maintains a friendly pace, keeping the energy welcoming even during late-night visits close to closing.