Valducci's Pizza

When you’re in the middle of a ShopRite run and the pizza craving hits, Valducci’s on Hylan Boulevard is your move. Since 1989, this Staten Island staple has been cranking out thin, crispy slices right inside the store—granting you the rare liberty of browsing the aisles with a slice in hand and circling back for seconds on your way out. The pepperoni slice earns consistent shouts as one of the island’s best, and the sausage version has its own fans. Service is fast (often under five minutes) and friendly, making it a reliable lunch stop in the New Dorp area, even in a neighborhood packed with pizzerias. Beyond the shop’s own counter, the Valducci’s brand extends its reach with catering and a mobile pizza truck, bringing that same quick, satisfying pizza to weddings, corporate gatherings, and after-parties across the boroughs, New Jersey, and Connecticut. Reviews are mostly glowing, though a lone dissenter finds it overrated—but for a quick, quality bite without sacrificing your shopping momentum, it’s a tough combo to beat.