Tony's Pizza · 3145 Fulton St | New York

Operating as a Fulton Street hole-in-the-wall for decades, this spot relies on a system of delivery and order-ahead pickup. The neighborhood experience is defined by starkly mixed reviews. While some regulars appreciate the consistent portions, others caution against unpredictable pricing and long waits. Recent feedback highlights a gamble on quality control, pointing to burnt pies and friction with the staff and owner, making a quick meal here a highly variable experience.