Toasties E. 51st

Navigating the menu is an exercise in choice, featuring around 45 sandwich options alongside large beet salads, cookies, and chips. The counter handles the rush efficiently, keeping wait times brief even when lines stretch. While you can eat inside, the dine-in setup is tiny and cramped, making this a spot optimized for a grab-and-go meal or a quick delivery rather than a relaxed sit-down experience.