The Whaler's Inn

Guests staying in the Hoxie House found it "every bit as charming and cozy as described," with porch rocking chairs made for sitting out at night. The rooms are individually decorated, and the on-site restaurant, The Shipwright's Daughter, draws particular praise. Handwritten notes from staff and cookies at check-in add a personal touch. Some visitors note the high prices and limited parking, so it's worth planning ahead for a spot.