The Pizza Parlor

The Pizza Parlor is a modern take on the classic New York style pizzeria in Staten Island, NY. Beyond the usual pies, the menu surprises with creative dishes like Italian Egg Rolls and Chicken Parm Mac and Cheese, while everything is prepared fresh daily using premium ingredients, including Grade A Angus beef from a local butcher. The pizza itself is a local favorite: big, cheesy, with perfectly crisp edges, and it’s consistently hot and fresh. The friendly, welcoming vibe and easy-on-the-wallet prices make it a go-to for families and neighbors alike. It also handles catering well—one satisfied customer fed a crowd of over fifty at a baby shower with half trays of chicken francese, marsala, and parm, pasta with oil and garlic, salad, calamari, mac and cheese bites, and multiple pies, all to rave reviews. While the dine-in and pickup experience earns high marks, a few delivery orders have been mixed up, so you might want to double-check your order when it arrives.