The Original Little Italy
This no-frills Manhattan counter serves up classic, crispy-crust New York slices and sandwiches with a welcoming hole-in-the-wall vibe.
- Mon – Fri, 10:00 – 20:00; Sat, 10:00 – 17:00
- $
- 2 East 39th Street
- 4.5 (396 reviews)
Description
Operating since the late 1960s, this stand-alone slice shop has migrated through several Midtown locations, including the old Commodore Hotel and Grand Central, before landing at its current spot off Fifth Avenue on East 39th Street. Behind its modest storefront, the menu features specialty options like the Robusta pizza with spicy sausage and the grandma's pepperoni with fresh mozzarella, singled out for its rich sauce and generous toppings. It is a straightforward, budget-friendly stop where the owner's hands-on hospitality matches the quality of the food.