The Goodfellas Pizzeria of Sunnyside

Behind the storefront is a humble, clean, and bright space typical of neighborhood pizzerias. Beyond the standard options, the kitchen bakes Sicilian and White pizzas, calzones, and hot heroes. Slices feature a generously applied, slightly sweet sauce and gooey, buttery cheese, though consistency can vary, with the occasional slice leaning average and greasy. The neighborhood feel is anchored by the owner, who often takes the time to introduce the menu options in detail.