Supreme Pizza NY
An East Harlem halal pizzeria turning out slices, specialty pies, and beef patties late into the night.
- Mon – Sun, 09:00 – 04:00 (+1)
- $
- 200 E 116th St
- 4.4 (58 reviews)
Description
Beyond pizza, the counter runs a late-night menu of wings, sandwiches, and pasta for delivery and takeout. Patrons generally report respectful staff and decent pricing, though food consistency varies—with complaints pointing to cold, repeatedly reheated slices alongside missing advertised specials.
Good to know
Open until 4 AM