NYC Tacos With a Self Serve Salsa Bar on W 28th St

Taqueria by El Prieto NYC keeps the menu focused on tacos, mulitas, quesadillas, and burritos at 139 W 28th Street. The small Manhattan counter leans into street food energy, with meats served on fresh tortillas and marinated pork called out as a local favorite.

The move here is the self serve condiments bar, where house salsas, fresh guacamole, and a wide spread of toppings let every taco take a different turn. Limited standup seating changes the rhythm of the visit, making this a quick bite rather than a long table session. The kitchen runs daily from 11 AM to 1 AM, giving the late window a clear edge. Expect a brief line when the counter is busy, then build a mix of formats and taste across the salsa lineup. The 4.8 average across 1,541 ratings adds context for a spot that keeps the order casual, customizable, and moving.