Shake Shack

4.2 (8,541)restaurant

366 Columbus Avenue

Once a Madison Square Park hot dog cart, this spot is known for its crispy-edged burgers and thick frozen custard.

Get directions

Description

This fast-casual spot draws crowds for its dependable patties and fries that stay crispy even when cold. However, the experience comes with clear trade-offs. Seating inside is limited, and peak hours often bring slow service alongside inconsistent cleanliness, with trash sometimes neglected during busy rushes. It works best as a quick bite if you are prepared for a hectic, high-traffic environment.


Selected reviews


Good to know

Slow peak service

Also featured in

Ask Karpo for more information.