Sal & Paul's Pizzeria

The menu extends past basic slices to include Sicilian pizza, pan pies, margarita pizza, and baby pies. Slices feature a soft, pillowy crust with a distinct chew, staying non-greasy even with pepperoni. Beyond the oven, the shop offers flavor-mixed slushies alongside its food, served by a staff praised for friendly, attentive service. While some guests note that shop cleanliness could be improved, this long-standing neighborhood spot continues to draw loyal locals for straightforward, classic NYC options.