Rocky's & Nicky's Pizzeria II

A cozy Bay Ridge counter serving up hot, quick slices and classic Italian comfort food with a nostalgic Brooklyn vibe.

  • Mon – Sun, 11:00 – 23:00
  • $
  • 6824 Colonial Rd
  • 4.2 (332 reviews)
Order on Slice

Description

The menu goes beyond standard rounds to include custom Sicilian pies, calzones, hot heroes, and pasta platters, alongside desserts like tiramisu and cannolis. While you can eat here, the setup is strictly self-serve with a few tables and no table servers. It functions best as a low-friction neighborhood stop—handy for a quick vodka slice when you want to satisfy hunger without overthinking it. Opinions on the overall food quality and pricing are mixed, but it remains a straightforward, reliable fallback for local pickup and delivery.


Good to know

Outdoor seatingQuick service

Ask Karpo for more information.