Ralph's Famous Italian · 70-52 Austin | New York

Established in 1928 after the founder immigrated from Italy, this Austin Street spot is still run by the family's grandchildren. The interior features a model LIRR train on the wall and an awkward window bench. Counter staff frequently hand out free samples, helping you choose between options like mango ice and toasted marshmallow. Keep in mind that service can feel rushed, and some customers find the soft serve melts quickly once they step outside.