Prince Street Pizza

A tiny Nolita slice shop famous for its thick, crispy Sicilian squares, especially the pepperoni-heaped Spicy Spring.

  • Mon – Tue, Sun, 10:00 – 03:00 (+1); Wed, 10:00 – 00:00 (+1); Thu – Sat, 10:00 – 05:00 (+1)
  • $
  • 27 Prince Street
  • 4.4 (9165 reviews)

Description

Situated between Mott and Elizabeth streets, the original shop runs on a compact, walk-in setup built for ordering and leaving quickly. Beyond the standard pepperoni options, the counter showcases alternatives like the Spicy Vodka slice, the ricotta-dolloped Four Cheese, and the Naughty Pizza. Regulars often pair their slices with hot honey served on the side to add sweet heat to the crunchy Sicilian crust. The space is tight and busy, but the line moves fast.

Good to know

Offers deliveryPickup availableCatering availableHas triangle slices