Pizza Plus
This no-frills East Harlem pizzeria is a neighborhood go-to for quick slices, beef pepperoni, and buffalo chicken pies.
- Mon – Sat, 11:00 – 19:00
- $
- 2253 3rd Ave
- 3.4 (70 reviews)
Description
The menu extends beyond pizza to include pasta dishes and fried chicken, though local feedback on the food is highly divided. While some regulars claim the pizza is the best in the neighborhood, others describe it as flavorless and recommend avoiding the non-pizza options altogether. For those eating in, the venue is a tight squeeze with very few tables.
Good to know
No cards acceptedNo ATM on site