Pete's Tavern

Operating on East 18th Street since 1864, the historic landmark holds onto deep neighborhood roots and literary lore linked to past regulars like O. Henry.

The menu centers on solid American comfort food—spanning chicken pot pie, chicken parmesan, and fried zucchini chips—poured alongside the tavern's signature 1864 House Ale. Up on the second floor, a private Speakeasy room accommodates events. During the winter season, the space shifts into high gear, drawing crowds under an overhead canopy of red ceiling lights and thousands of holiday decorations.