P & M Classic Pizza & Restaurant
This Hamilton Heights fixture serves crisp Neapolitan and Sicilian slices alongside comforting red-sauce classics.
- Mon – Thu, Sat, 10:30 – 21:00; Fri, 10:30 – 22:00
- 1747 Amsterdam Avenue
- 4.7 (324 reviews)
People
PaulOwner
MauricioOwner
Description
Run by Paul and Mauricio for over 18 years, this Harlem staple features an open kitchen and an older-looking dining area. Regulars prize the shop's classic NYC crust, which is baked until crispy, slightly chewy, and bubbled at the rim. While it operates as a straightforward counter, the kitchen serves more than quick slices, drawing a lunch crowd for home-style lasagna and hearty plates. The atmosphere is relaxed, friendly, and unpretentious.