Order Custom Cakes on Staten Island at Annadale Bakery

For custom cakes on Staten Island, Annadale Bakery at 821 Annadale Road is a neighborhood bakery that pairs made-to-order cakes and Italian cookies with a savory sandwich counter. Reviewers single out its custom cake work for fair pricing and for accommodating short turnaround times, which makes it a practical first call when you need a last-minute cake for a birthday or a family table. Annadale Bakery hours start at 8 AM every day, so you can order or pick up before work.

The closing time shifts through the week: 6:30 PM Monday to Thursday, 7 PM on Friday and Saturday, and 5 PM on Sunday. That makes weekday evenings and Saturdays the widest pickup windows, while Sunday needs an earlier plan. The shop holds a 4.7 rating from 504 reviews and sits in the $$ price band, a useful signal if you are comparing cake shops on budget as well as speed.

The honest caveat comes from the same reviews. Visitor feedback notes occasional inconsistency with order specifications on detailed requests, so the more elaborate the design, the more it pays to spell out every detail and check the cake before you leave. The next question is how to place that order well, and what else is worth carrying out of the door with it.

Address: 821 Annadale Road, Staten Island, New York
Area: Annadale Road in the borough of Staten Island, New York City
Hours: Monday–Thursday 8 AM–6:30 PM · Friday–Saturday 8 AM–7 PM · Sunday 8 AM–5 PM
Phone: (929) 284-3400
Rating: 4.7 out of 5 from 504 reviews
Price signal: $$
Known for: custom cakes, Italian cookies and hefty sandwiches such as the 'Terrible Eddies #1'
Good to know: check cake orders at pickup; last-minute cake requests are a reviewer-noted strength

Ordering a custom cake at Annadale Bakery works best as a short, specific conversation rather than a loose idea. The bakery builds its daily business around custom sweets and counter orders, so the cake request sits alongside walk-in trade at the same counter. Start by calling (929) 284-3400 or stopping in during opening hours, and come ready with the occasion, the size you need, the flavour, the wording and the date you want to collect it.

Reviewers praise the custom cake work for fair pricing and for handling tight timelines, which is why this counter suits a birthday that crept up on you or a family gathering planned at short notice. That speed is the reason to choose it. The trade-off is precision: feedback mentions occasional inconsistency with order specifications on detailed requests. If your design has exact colours, lettering or several decorative elements, write it down, repeat it back when you order and ask how the details will be confirmed.

At pickup, open the box at the counter and check the cake before you leave, which is the single habit that protects a last-minute order. Simpler designs carry less risk, so if timing is tight, a classic cake with clear lettering is the safer request. Exact prices are not published in the listing, so ask for a quote when you order.

Annadale Bakery is not only a cake stop. The everyday counter carries Italian cookies and baked sweets for planned pickups, and the kitchen turns out a savory menu anchored by items like the 'Terrible Eddies #1' sandwich, which the listing describes as one of its hefty sandwiches. That mix of sweet trays and a real lunch order is what sets this counter apart from a pure cake shop: you can collect a celebration cake and leave with something to eat now.

For a cake pickup, a box of Italian cookies is the natural add-on for a party table or a host gift, and it does not need the planning a custom cake does. For a weekday visit, the sandwich side of the menu makes the stop useful at lunchtime, and reviewers mention delicious sandwiches as often as they mention cakes. The shop sits in the $$ price band, so expect neighborhood-bakery pricing rather than a high-end patisserie bill.

Who it suits: families ordering for birthdays and gatherings, locals who want a cookie tray without a long wait, and anyone in the Annadale area looking for a substantial sandwich near Annadale Road. The limitation is information: the listing does not publish a full menu or item prices, so ask at the counter about what is in the case that day rather than relying on a fixed list.

Timing matters more here than at most bakeries because the hours change across the week. Annadale Bakery opens at 8 AM every day. It closes at 6:30 PM from Monday to Thursday, stays open until 7 PM on Friday and Saturday, and closes earlier at 5 PM on Sunday. If you are collecting a cake for a Sunday lunch or afternoon party, plan the pickup well before the 5 PM close, and ideally earlier in the day so there is time to fix anything that does not match your order.

For a party on Saturday evening, the 7 PM Saturday close gives the longest weekend window, but leaving pickup to the last hour removes your margin if a detail needs changing. A morning pickup is the calmer choice: the counter opens at 8 AM, and an early stop also lines up with picking up cookies or a sandwich for the day. Friday works the same way for weekend celebrations.

For a last-minute cake, call (929) 284-3400 as early in the day as you can and confirm the pickup time before you set out. The listing does not include delivery, parking or reservation details, so check those directly with the shop rather than assuming them. Holiday hours are not listed either, so confirm around public holidays.

Where can I get custom cakes on Staten Island at short notice?
Annadale Bakery at 821 Annadale Road is a strong option. Reviewers praise its custom cake work for fair pricing and for accommodating short turnaround times, which suits last-minute birthday or family cake requests.

What are Annadale Bakery's hours?
It opens at 8 AM every day. It closes at 6:30 PM Monday to Thursday, at 7 PM on Friday and Saturday, and at 5 PM on Sunday, so Sunday pickups need an earlier plan.

What is Annadale Bakery's phone number?
You can call the bakery on (929) 284-3400. Calling ahead is the simplest way to discuss a custom cake, confirm a pickup time or ask what is in the case that day.

Does Annadale Bakery sell more than cakes?
Yes. Alongside custom cakes it sells Italian cookies and baked sweets, and its kitchen runs a savory menu anchored by hefty sandwiches such as the 'Terrible Eddies #1'.

How is Annadale Bakery rated?
It holds a 4.7 out of 5 rating from 504 reviews. Customers appreciate the custom cakes and the sandwiches, though some note occasional inconsistency with order specifications on detailed requests.

How can I make sure my custom cake order comes out right?
Write down the size, flavour, wording and design, repeat the details back when you order, and check the cake at the counter before you leave. Simpler designs carry less risk when time is tight.

Is Annadale Bakery expensive?
The listing places it in the $$ price band, and reviewers describe the custom cake pricing as fair. Exact prices are not published, so ask for a quote when you place your order.

Keep planning around Annadale after your cake order. A guide to four spots on Annadale Road covers an Italian sandwich shop, an event hall restaurant, a neighborhood bakery and a Sicilian pizzeria. For another celebration order, a Staten Island custom cake shop puts real fruit in the layers on Amboy Road, and a family-owned bakery offers breads and pastries with pan-European and American bakes. Farther out, try Staten Island Armenian food with fresh khachapuri, or made-to-order cannolis and breakfast steps from Prospect Park.