Nonna's Pizzeria and Italian Kitchen

Operating on Nassau Avenue with two decades of kitchen experience, the staff serves a broad menu of Italian dishes alongside customizable pizzas. Beyond the counter, you can build your own vegan options with melty cheese or buy their signature pizza dough cheaply for home baking. The team is known for patiently explaining the rotating slice lineup, though reviews note occasional inconsistencies in order accuracy and freshness. For events, they also provide catering packages featuring their pepperoni and namesake Nonna pies.