
Nelly's Cake & Party Supply
This Brooklyn bakery specializes in traditional Dominican cakes topped with sweet, piped suspiro frosting.
- Mon – Sat, 09:00 – 18:00; Sun, Open 24 hours
- $$$
- 597 New Lots Ave
- 4.0 (80 reviews)
Description




Operating for over twenty-five years, this neighborhood staple builds custom cakes for celebrations, featuring traditional fillings like pineapple and vanilla custard. Longtime customers value the bakery for its budget-friendly pricing, reliable pickup times, and nostalgic decorations like piped suspiro flowers. While the custom designs consistently match customer requests, the texture of the sponge itself can sometimes lean dry under the heavy layers of icing.