Mr. C’s Bakery

4.2 (306)bakery

5101 Church Avenue

This Brooklyn staple serves warm Caribbean-style breads, sweet currents rolls, and fresh pastries daily.

Get directions

People

Sir ConradOwner

Description

Historically connected to Conrad’s Bakery, this neighborhood spot serves Caribbean-style baked goods that evoke Trinidadian home baking. Alongside daily loaves, the counter features patties, breakfast bakes, and sweets like sponge and slice cakes. While the staff is often noted for friendly gestures—like helping with last-minute birthday cakes—the service can occasionally feel tense when navigating specific line rules, such as designated queues for bread.


Selected reviews


Good to know

Bread-only lineLast-minute cakes

Also featured in

Ask Karpo for more information.