Millie's of Staten Island

Beyond the signature pies, the kitchen turns out sandwiches, seafood, and classic bar fare. The drink menu supports the relaxed vibe with cocktails and an impressive lineup of brews, served in an environment that fits both solo drinks and group holiday dinners. Most visitors report friendly, attentive service and reasonable value, though the kitchen's output can occasionally miss, noted in a recent complaint about a bland burger and fries.