Midnight Cookies & Cream Westchester

Tucked into the back of a plaza across from McDonald's, this counter leans into monster-sized cookies served warm alongside artisanal scoops and well-packaged shakes. Beyond recipes like Red Velvet, the selection cycles through seasonal creations and options for special diets, giving the hefty bakes plenty of variety from visit to visit. Service extends past midnight on weekends, making it a go-to stop when substantial late-night sugar cravings strike in Westchester.