Masters Pizza & Ice Cream
This spacious Sunset Park spot pairs crispy pizza with a huge selection of ice cream and frozen slushies under one roof.
- Mon – Sun, 11:00 – 22:00
- $$
- 5201 5th Ave
- 3.8 (71 reviews)
Description
Located on 5th Avenue, this neighborhood joint is appreciated for its budget-friendly prices and a staff that treats regulars like family. However, visitors report inconsistent food quality and service. While loyalists value the affordability, others warn of kitchen missteps, citing greasy calamari and underbaked pies delivered cold with toppings added as an afterthought. It remains a handy stop for quick combos, provided you catch them on a good day.
Good to know
In-store promosApp promotionsSlush Puppies