Mario's Meats & Gourmet Deli
A Middle Village butcher praised for fresh mozzarella, imported Italian cold cuts, and standout prepared dishes, though some shoppers dispute the scale.
- Mon – Thu, 08:00 – 18:00; Fri, 08:00 – 19:00; Sat, 07:30 – 18:00; Sun, 08:00 – 14:00
- $$
- 75-55 Metropolitan Ave, Middle Village, New York, 11379
- 4.5 (209 reviews)
Description
This Middle Village butcher is named a Boar's Head Deli of Distinction, known for freshly pounded chicken cutlets and hand-rolled sandwiches. Visitors praise the selection of imported Italian cold cuts, fresh mozzarella, and prepared dishes like fish salad, with some making the trip from Manhattan. However, one customer reported a disputed trim: a ribeye weighed at 2.45 lbs, then trimmed after charging, re-weighed at 1.71 lbs the next day — nearly a pound off.
Good to know
Check meat weightAsk to weigh before trim