Mario's Meats & Gourmet Deli

4.5 (209)shop

A Middle Village butcher praised for fresh mozzarella, imported Italian cold cuts, and standout prepared dishes, though some shoppers dispute the scale.

Find on Google Maps

Description

This Middle Village butcher is named a Boar's Head Deli of Distinction, known for freshly pounded chicken cutlets and hand-rolled sandwiches. Visitors praise the selection of imported Italian cold cuts, fresh mozzarella, and prepared dishes like fish salad, with some making the trip from Manhattan. However, one customer reported a disputed trim: a ribeye weighed at 2.45 lbs, then trimmed after charging, re-weighed at 1.71 lbs the next day — nearly a pound off.


Selected reviews


Good to know

Check meat weightAsk to weigh before trim

Also featured in

Ask Karpo for more information.