Madison Street Pizza

4.5 (133)restaurant

223 Madison Street

A cozy neighborhood slice shop in Manhattan known for generous toppings and its popular spicy buffalo pizza.

Order now

Description

This compact space runs an efficient counter operation, making it a reliable stop for a quick bite or a family dinner. Visitors stopping in can chat with the owner or grab the two-slice special. However, off-site dining can yield different results; delivery orders have occasionally arrived lacking crispness and flavor, presenting a contrast to the praise from in-person diners.


Selected reviews


Good to know

2 slices for $5

Also featured in

Ask Karpo for more information.