Made in New York Pizza
This Upper West Side pizzeria delivers classic, no-nonsense New York slices and thick, spicy pepperoni squares.
- Mon – Thu, Sun, 11:00 – 23:00; Fri – Sat, 11:00 – 01:00 (+1)
- $
- 2563 Broadway
- 3.6 (64 reviews)
Description
The kitchen builds its dough on local New York water and high-quality cheeses, topped with a light sauce. Service at the Broadway spot is quick and direct. While you can grab whatever is on display, you can also have a custom half-and-half pie baked fresh on the spot. Pricing gets mixed reviews—some find it surprisingly cheap, others a bit pricey but worth it—but the draw is a reliable, uncomplicated counter experience.