Lillo's Tomato Pies
4.7 (78)restaurant
4.7 (78)$1.50 – $3.00
A Forest Hills pizzeria imports Trenton-style coal-fired pies and NJ cheesesteaks, earning praise for hefty beef portions.
Description
Family-run spot on Continental Ave brings Trenton-style coal-fired pies to Forest Hills, with generous beef-topped Philly cheesesteaks on fresh bread. Reviewers note the pizza's charred crust and the cheesesteaks' hefty size — one even calls the quality surprising for NYC. Despite a broken AC on one visit, staff kept working hard, and the wait for the cheesesteaks proved worthwhile.
Selected reviews
Good to know
casual
