Liberty Bagels 5th Ave

4.4 (2,006)bakery

16 E 58th St

A bustling spot near Fifth Avenue serving hand-rolled bagels and creative sandwiches with remarkably fast service.

Get directions

Description

Inside the snug space, the kitchen operates like a well-oiled machine to handle long lines. Beyond standard spreads, the specialty options include a sweet French toast bagel, a jalapeño everything option, and vibrant rainbow bagels. Diners can order combinations like lemon dill lox on onion, the salmon-filled Gold Coast sandwich, or bacon, egg, and cheese with scallion cream cheese. While a few tables are available inside, the counter-serve setup is built for speed, with self-serve drinks to grab while waiting in the queue.


Selected reviews


Also featured in

Ask Karpo for more information.