La Pizza Italia · 493 Amsterdam Ave | New York

The menu expands on standard pies with vegan and gluten-free options, alongside square pizzas, hot heroes, and pasta. Slices here are cut large, built on a thin crust that balances a crisp exterior with a doughy center—though some note it leans on the firmer side. Popular options like pepperoni and Margherita share the counter with casual two-slice deals that include a free soda, drawing neighborhood locals looking for a straightforward, late-night bite.