La Casa Mia
A Sheepshead Bay neighborhood spot known for thin-crust Grandma pies and a signature chicken Caesar salad pizza.
- Mon – Sun, 11:00 – 22:15
- $
- 1420 Sheepshead Bay Rd
- 4.1 (359 reviews)
Description
Beyond the signature pies, this casual spot serves wings and pasta dishes in a warm dining room with clean tables. The service is run by welcoming owners, though visitor feedback notes that quality consistency can occasionally vary depending on the slice you choose. For those eating at home, they run their own delivery service that lands hot food on the table quickly, complete with plates and cups. It remains a popular stop for a quick bite, with some former locals even making road trips back just to grab a pie.
Good to know
Order via Slice Life20-25 min deliveryPlates & cups included