Janie's Life-Changing Baked Goods

4.7 (399)bakery

434 Amsterdam Avenue

Famous for crispy pie crust cookies, this bakery supports young women through mentorship and second-chance employment.

Get directions

People

Janie DeeganOwner

Description

The bakery's mission is rooted in its founder's recovery from addiction and homelessness. At the counter, the focus is on a hybrid treat: pie-style fillings wrapped in cookie form. The flavor lineup includes apple, pecan, and berry options, baked to achieve a soft, crumbly texture reminiscent of a pie topping. While visitor opinions on pricing diverge—some consider them a pricey splurge, others find them affordable—the compact shop maintains a welcoming feel, with staff who guide you through the day's flavors.


Selected reviews


Also featured in

Ask Karpo for more information.