Insomnia Cookies
Warm, freshly baked cookies and ice cream sandwiches, ready for late-night pickup or delivery on Staten Island.
- Mon – Wed, 11:00 – 01:00 (+1); Thu – Fri, 11:00 – 03:00 (+1); Sat, 12:00 – 03:00 (+1); Sun, 12:00 – 01:00 (+1)
- 422 Forest Ave
- 3.2 (39 reviews)
Description
This location spares locals a trip to the city to satisfy a late-night sweet tooth. Inside, cookies are kept in specialized warming equipment so they stay hot for quick pickup. While daytime visits tend to be quiet, the shop gets crowded during peak nighttime hours, which can sometimes lead to a hurried counter experience when lines start to build.