Hilltop Tavern

Positioned on Prospect Park West, the tavern—co-created by the team behind Alchemy—offers a choice between indoor and outdoor seating. While the staff is praised for warm, welcoming service, visitors note that the experience varies. Brunch remains a popular draw for dishes like cheddar-and-bacon omelettes with roasted potatoes. By contrast, the dinner menu receives mixed reviews for consistency, with some diners reporting dry entrees and prep issues, set against a lively, sometimes noisy room.