Gus's Pizzeria

4.3 (230)restaurant

1750 Bath Ave

A Bensonhurst neighborhood spot pairing classic Sicilian slices and heroes with Mexican tortas and flautas.

Order now

Description

Following its transition from Nicky's Pizza, this local corner has expanded its reach well beyond the pizza oven. While the counter still turns out regular round pies and pasta, the menu now branches into burgers and salads. If you decide to eat in, expect a limited self-service setup with a few tables and no servers. Local reception has been highly mixed since the change in ownership; some regulars drop by for the regular slices and a cold Vanilla Coke, while others warn of pricing issues and a drop in overall quality.


Selected reviews


Good to know

Free deliveryCurbside pickup

Also featured in

Ask Karpo for more information.