Gooey on the Inside
Massive six-ounce cookies pair crisp, golden edges with soft, molten centers at this cozy Manhattan bakery.
- Mon – Thu, Sun, 12:00 – 22:00; Fri – Sat, 12:00 – 00:00 (+1)
- Cookies: $8.15 each; Molten Cookie in a Jar: $15 (8oz) / $23 (16oz); Croissandwich: $19 each; Dirty Dough / Warm Scoopable Cookie dough: $15; Cookie Bites: $14 for 6 pcs
- 119 Christopher Street
- 4.3 (32 reviews)
Description
What began in a Chelsea kitchen has evolved into a Manhattan staple for unapologetically rich baking. Guided by the founder's background—blending Caribbean roots with memories of cold Canadian winters—the bakery focuses on capturing the contrast between a caramelized outer edge and a molten center. In addition to the signature cookies, which are served warm and include popular vegan options, the menu features scoopable cookie dough and jars of warm cookies. The shop is also known for its exceptionally welcoming staff, making it a comforting detour for a daytime treat or a late-night sweet fix.