El Pitallito Mexican Restaurant

3.9 (192)restaurant

3854 Broadway

This Washington Heights spot serves homestyle Mexican classics, featuring rich mole and hand-pressed tortillas.

Get directions

People

StevenOther

Description

This family-owned Broadway spot offers a menu built on daily-fresh preparations, ranging from birria tacos and al pastor to weekly favorites like chile rellenos. While the kitchen excels at these staples and turns out large portions of fresh guacamole, some visitors note consistency issues with complex orders. The experience is anchored by friendly service, making it a relaxed choice for a casual meal paired with margaritas, even if opinions on its exact level of authenticity occasionally vary.


Selected reviews


Good to know

Online orderingPickup and delivery

Also featured in

Ask Karpo for more information.