El Arrollito

Tucked away on Delafield Avenue, El Arrollito is a casual Staten Island spot where the hospitality is as warm as the freshly pressed tortillas. The kitchen prepares everything to order, even rolling out and cooking the tortillas right in front of diners. While the tacos—including a standout shrimp version—are a major draw, the menu also features hefty, budget-friendly tortas. Run by a sweet and welcoming owner, it offers a slice of authentic Mexican cooking in a relaxed, friendly neighborhood setting.