Where to Bar Hop on First Avenue in Midtown East?
Three First Avenue cocktail bars in Midtown East rated 4.5 to 5: amari at Bar Enzo, absinthe at Shaken Not Stirred, and Guinness at Sutton Bar Room.
Midtown East Cocktail Bars on the Map
Bar Enzo: Amari to Open on First Avenue
Green banquettes sit beneath rear windows at Bar Enzo, opposite dark stools and a reflective counter. Illuminated bottle shelves and hanging glass lights frame an Italian-American family-gathering atmosphere. The drinks list centers on custom cocktails and amari, with wine pairings extending the choices. An attentive bartender can pair a martini with a snack. Service runs Wednesday through Sunday, 5:00 PM to 12:00 AM. Monday and Tuesday are closed.
Shaken Not Stirred: First Avenue After Hours
At Shaken Not Stirred, cocktails start with natural ingredients and a shake with ice to order. The pours run sweeter and lighter in strength, with absinthe available for a different pace. Sashimi, crispy calamari, and savory small plates extend the food choices. Nostalgic music fills the intimate lounge, where the date-night setting suits a later stop. Thursday and Friday service starts at 3:00 PM and ends at 2:00 AM the next morning.
Sutton Bar Room: A Sutton Place Final Round
Sutton Bar Room welcomes solo visitors. Stools line the long wooden counter in its vintage-style interior. Happy hour brings drink specials. Choose a craft cocktail or a pint of Guinness. The bar allows outside food, including delivery to accompany drinks. Monday nights feature lively trivia. Doors stay open until 4:00 AM the next day throughout the week. The room can fill quickly. Check the crowd before settling in for a conversation.
