City Line Bakery: Brooklyn, NYC

While the flavors remain popular, ordering custom creations has become unpredictable. Longtime patrons note a shift since a key baker departed, leaving custom cake design consistency highly variable. Lettering and presentation are hit-or-miss; customers report issues ranging from crystallized icing and air bubbles to poor penmanship, though a newer young decorator is noted for doing the best writing. Staff interactions can also lean sassy, making this spot a better fit for those prioritizing flavor over polished aesthetics.