Cheesy Pizza

While some drop in for the friendly service, visitor experiences here vary. Some patrons have reported quality issues like burnt cheese pizza and sandwiches with stale bread and unmelted cheese. Additionally, the pizzas included in the shop's promotions are smaller than the regular size—a detail not always clearly communicated—and you may have to wait if the promotional meal is not already prepared. Old-timers also whisper about a possible connection to a closed Downtown Brooklyn pizzeria of the same name.