Carvel
A neighborhood favorite for soft-serve, custom sundaes, and beautifully decorated ice cream cakes.
- Mon – Sat, 11:00 – 22:00; Sun, 11:00 – 21:30
- $
- 280-30 Marsh Ave
- 4.5 (130 reviews)
Description
This Staten Island outpost of the classic Carvel chain has built a loyal following for its soft-serve and custom cakes, and the reviews back it up. Locals rave about the wide selection of cake designs—from birthdays to bespoke requests—and the staff’s willingness to accommodate unusual sundae combos (pineapple and hot fudge, anyone?). They even nail cake inscriptions with calligrapher-level precision. Keep it in mind for a late-night craving, as this spot stays open later than most. The shop is consistently clean, and prices are easy on the wallet, making it a go-to for celebrating without breaking the bank.